| 1 | Rich Gannon | QB | Oakland Raiders |
| 2 | Doug Flutie | QB | San Diego Chargers |
| 3 | Marshall Faulk | RB | St Louis Rams |
| 4 | Duce Staley | RB | Philadelphia Eagles |
| 5 | Marvin Harrison | WR | Indianapolis Colts |
| 6 | Germaine Crowell | WR | Detroit Lions |
| 7 | Shannon Sharpe | TE | Baltimore Ravens |
| 8 | Matt Stover | K | Baltimore Ravens |
| 9 | Pittsburgh Steelers | DEF |