| 1 | Peyton Manning | QB | Indianapolis Colts |
| 2 | Brian Griese | QB | Denver Broncos |
| 3 | Ricky Williams | RB | New Orleans Saints |
| 4 | Tiki Barber | RB | New York Giants |
| 5 | Joe Horn | WR | New Orleans Saints |
| 6 | Troy Brown | WR | New England Patriots |
| 7 | Chad Lewis | TE | Philadelphia Eagles |
| 8 | Todd Peterson | K | Seattle Seahawks |
| 9 | New York Jets | DEF |